Dead Reckoning: Memories of the Bangladesh War is a controversial book on the Bangladesh Liberation War written by Sarmila Bose. The book caused. Read Dead Reckoning book reviews & author details and more at mtn-i.info Through a detailed investigation of events on the ground, Sarmila Bose. Sarmila Bose's book Dead Reckoning: Memories of the Bangladesh War serves as the most sophisticated propaganda for those who.
|Language:||English, Spanish, Portuguese|
|Distribution:||Free* [*Registration needed]|
mtn-i.info: Dead Reckoning: Memories of the Bangladesh War ( ): Sarmila Bose: Books. The eyes would widen and the head move from side to side in the striking Bengali gesture of affirmation. "How many were killed?" we would. Dead Reckoning - Memories of the Bangladesh War- By Sarmila Bose - Free ebook download as PDF File .pdf), Text File .txt) or read book online for free.
That was the only mechanism to ensure critical service delivery programmes continued in the country. This reflects her inadequate knowledge of the milestones of our nationalist movements and struggle for ultimate freedom.
I would ask the author to kindly trace the history of Bengali nationalist struggle that started after when Muhammad Ali Jinnah announced Urdu as the only state language of Pakistan. Further to the instant protests in , Bengalis shed blood on February 21, to establish Bangla as the state language. The sweeping victory of Jukto Front in and subsequent movements to ensure constitutional rights as well as to resist political subjugation and economic deprivation bear credible evidence that the struggle for freedom progressed through relevant and appropriate phases that eventually led to the emergence of independent, sovereign Bangladesh.
This is a shameful part of the discourse that falls short of facts and reason. It fails to assess the contents of a full-fledged war of liberation and tries to dilute its importance, inevitability, significance and outcome. How would she look at the liberation movements in different regions that saw the emergence of states, especially in the post-World War II era? She has tried to undermine the struggle of a valiant nation for freedom.
This gross misinterpretation and misrepresentation of facts erode the possibility of even the slightest degree of acceptability of her findings.
The book remains vague on the details of the atrocities committed by the Pakistani occupation forces. What the Pakistani forces and their agents did from March till December clearly meets the definitional and functional classification of genocide by the United Nations, as well as the criterion for genocide as applied by International Criminal Court.
The author has highlighted only selected military actions of Pakistan and overlooked the key dimensions of genocide.
Sadly, she has fabricated theories to suit her interests and tried to downplay the widespread and barbaric acts of genocide, rape, arson, and planned ethnic cleansing by the Pakistani occupation forces. There is ample evidence of mass killings and destructions provided by scholars and historians and validated through international documents and global media. Even some authors from India and Pakistan have recorded their findings that confirm the occurrence of genocide in East Bengal in As regards her view that minorities fled across the border "not due to atrocities by Pakistani occupation forces but threat and torture by majority segment of the population", this is a gross distortion of facts and massive deviation from historical truth.
Bangladesh has an impeccable track record of communal harmony and social togetherness, and this has been a key strength in Bangladesh's social setting for centuries. Some documents confirm that after the historic March 7 speech by Bangabandhu, Bangladesh became independent and free from Pakistan rule.
In , people from all walks of life coordinated closely with the freedom fighters as well as people's representatives participating in the war. Bangabandhu's leadership and instructions and the responsibilities undertaken by the Mujibnagar government-in-exile carried the war to the final victory. In view of the above, I would like to request the author to revise her book to replace the untrue reflections and motivated myths. If you have a story to tell, make sure this is the story of the people, the story of reason and truth.
If you like to explore facts, you need to study with an open mind and ensure intellectual integrity. Please come up with a revised, logical and historically valid document that would highlight the great struggle of the people of Bangladesh in achieving freedom. Dr Mohammed Parvez Imdad is an economist and policy and governance analyst currently based in Manila, Philippines. Skip to main content. Home Opinion Perspective.
Mohammed Parvez Imdad. To contribute your article or letter to The Daily Star Opinion, see our guidelines for submission. Click here to download it for your device. The Daily Star Breaking news alert on your phone. Leave your comments Comment Policy. The year was marked by a bitter civil war within Pakistan and between India and Pakistan, backed respectively by the Soviet Union and the United States.
It was fought over the territory of East Pakistan, which seceded to become Bangladesh. The numbers mattered, and matter still, because they make the difference between seeing the war as a tragedy and seeing it as a terrible crime, indeed as a genocide.
Bose estimates that between 50, and , people died in One hundred thousand at most. In her own words: Many facts had been exaggerated, fabricated, distorted or concealed. Many people in responsible positions had repeated unsupported assertions without a thought; some people seemed to know that the nationalist mythologies were false and yet had done nothing to inform the public.
I came across some of the reviews and comments of people criticising Ms Bose, calling her an apologist, biased and some of them accused her of writing the record in favour of Pakistan Army. She did not portray President Yahya Khan an evil but a President who wanted to handover the government to the winners in Eastern and Western Pakistan. She mentioned about Army attack on a Hindu area in Decca, army operation in Dhaka university, anarchy in Chittagong, Tanagail operation by Pakistan Army and the worst of them all Thanapara operation.
Thanapara, which is recalled as the village of widows. Thanapara operation shamed the Pakistan Army as it crushed the Bengali rebellion in the Eastern Province. I did not find Ms Bose defending anyone; in fact she has raised some genuine questions about the figures like , deaths of Bengalis and , rapes of Bengali women.
She has raised the question about the figures of murdered Biharis and West Pakistanis settled in East Pakistan; people killed because of Indian Airforce bombing. There were more villains and one cannot single out Pakistan Army in the whole episode of violence which resulted in the creation of Bangladesh. Indian involvement, Bengali forces and Sheikh Mujibur Rehman were equally responsible.
She has questioned the figure or 93, prisoners of war in Indian custody, when total Army was not 93, in East Pakistan. She has challenged the facts with the records; she had conducted the interviews of people who lived the war.
Bose had really put her efforts in to bring the facts together and remained unbiased. I personally would wish to thank Ms Bose for her efforts to write such a marvellous book. Please study the provided facts and think rationally to find your own truth. Cartoons Letters Blogs. Facebook Twitter Instagram. Skip to primary navigation Skip to content Skip to primary sidebar Skip to footer.